Comparing Fictional Stories

Comparing fictional stories

The comparing fictional stories standard was a lot of fun to teach. We covered two comparisons of book sets seen here below. The RL domain asks students to be able to compare and contrast two fictional stories.

  • Kinder: With prompting and support, compare and contrast the adventures and experiences of characters in familiar stories.
  • 1st Grade: Compare and contrast the adventures and experiences of characters in stories.
  • 2nd Grade: Compare and contrast two or more versions of the same story (e.g., Cinderella stories) by different authors or from different cultures.
  • 3rd Grade: Compare and contrast the themes, settings, and plots of stories written by the same author about the same or similar characters (e.g., in books from a series)

Set 1

Little Red Hen Comparisons:

First, we started with The Little Red Hen. We took the original folk tale from Reading A-Z. Then, we compared it to a fractured folk tale. The Little Red Hen Makes a Pizza is a great comparison book for this!

Comparing two fictional stories using venn diagrams and graphic organizers

Interested in the Little Red Hen Makes a Pizza text? Here is an affiliate link to Amazon for the book.

Comparing two fictional stories using venn diagrams and graphic organizers

As a whole group, we completed these graphic organizers that I made for my class. In each box, the students had to write about the characters, events, and settings in the story. Then, they had to circle the similarities. Since they were circling the similarities, they could easily compare.

Set 2

More Little Red Hen fractured folk tales

After we compared and contrasted Little Red Hen and its fractured folk tale, it was time to compare other fictional stories. Now, we were going to compare two seasonal Little Red Hen. For these compare fictional stories activities, I read the stories aloud and asked students to complete a graphic organizer.

The Little Red Elf book cover

Interested in these texts? Here are affiliate links for you to grab them on Amazon…

Little Green Witch

Little Red Elf

Comparing two fictional stories using venn diagrams and graphic organizers

The picture included shows a beginning, middle, and end map we did after we read the story! We then filled out a comparison map I made where the students filled out information on both stories. Then, they circled what was similar.

Set 3

Blind Men and the Elephant & Seven Blind Mice

These two old folk tales can deliver strong messages and are great comparison pieces. In both stories, the characters are feeling things and trying to determine what it is.

Comparing two fictional stories using venn diagrams and graphic organizers
Seven Blind Mice book cover

Interested in these books? Here are affiliate links to Amazon…

The Blind Men and the Elephant

Seven Blind Mice

Comparing two fictional stories using venn diagrams and graphic organizers

We then finished comparing fictional stories with a Venn Diagram.

Need more Comparing Fiction resources?

I have an RL9 unit for 5 different grade levels! Check your grade level’s unit out.

Kindergarten — 1st Grade — 2nd Grade — 3rd Grade — 4th Grade

Plus I have a freebie that includes graphic organizers for books you compare and contrast in your classroom.

Graphic organizer freebie for teachers

If you’re looking for more content on literacy teaching…check out more blogs…

Comparing two fictional stories using venn diagrams and graphic organizers
Share on email
Email
Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Share on twitter
Twitter

You might also like...